3 min read16 min
The former minister for EU relations has called for more “clarity” in the conversation about the UK’s future relationship with the bloc.
Speaking ahead of Andy Burnham heading to Brussels for a major UK-EU summit on Friday, Nick Thomas-Symonds told PoliticsHome there is a risk of Westminster having a “fantasy debate” resulting in “unrealistic” ambitions that cannot be achieved.
The Labour MP also said the Prime Minister will ultimately need to clearly set out the relationship he wants the UK to have with the EU.
Burnham will head to Brussels tomorrow, where he hopes to strike a new UK-EU deal covering areas like food and drink and a youth mobility scheme.
The PM has said next month he will set out proposed options for Britain’s long-term relationship with the bloc, having previously said rejoining could be on the table.
Burnham has said this week that “at every stage the British people will be the boss”. He has also stressed that red lines included in Labour’s 2024 manifesto must remain in place in this Parliament. Those red lines ruled out rejoining the EU’s single market and customs union.
However, according to Thomas-Symonds, who was the Cabinet Office minister in charge of EU relations under Burnham’s predecessor Keir Starmer, the current conversation about the UK’s future relationship with the bloc needs more “clarity”.
“The question is precisely how close that [relationship] is… I think that each of those options we need just to have a bit more clarity about what the trade-offs actually are.
“At the moment, we’ve got some public debate where people are speculating about what the EU may or may not want in different scenarios. It’s not helpful,” he told PoliticsHome podcast The Rundown.
He continued: “Work by officials on both sides of the channel would be very helpful because otherwise we’re going to end up with some sort of a fantasy debate where people are saying they want particular options, but they like this bit, but they don’t want the bit they don’t like.
“When, as we know, the problem is we spend ages negotiating with ourselves and then come up with something that’s just unrealistic with the EU.”
Thomas-Symonds added that Burnham must not wait too long before setting out the relationship he wants to have with the EU.
“I think there has to be an endpoint to the debate,” he said.
“You can’t just let this run because what will happen is you’ve got the government and the Cabinet, which obviously has collective responsibility, so they all have to be very circumspect about what they say in public and can’t just go out expressing their personal views.
“I don’t think there’s anything wrong at all with making the public the boss in the process; my great hero, Harold Wilson, started that in 1975 with a referendum.
“This is one issue of all issues in British politics where that is so important, but I think there has to be an endpoint to the debate and the national conversation, and then at that point, clearly the Prime Minister has to come out and advocate for an option.”
The Rundown is presented by Alain Tolhurst, and is produced and edited by Ewan Cameron for Podot
- Click here to listen to the latest episode of The Rundown, or search for ‘PoliticsHome’ wherever you get your podcasts.